Friday, May 5, 2017

Who is Macon Detornay?

   As we read more and more of Angry Black White Boy by Adam Mansbach, I find myself more and more confused about Macon's nature. In the beginning, I was unsympathetic to him--I couldn't understand him because I didn't know his background. What attracted Macon to black culture? Why is he so invested in it? And why, did this Jewish white boy get so offended when his taxi customers talked flippantly about a black woman? When I first started the book, it sounded like Macon was just trying to be somebody special and boost his own ego by being the only white boy willing to go to such lengths for the black community. I didn't see him as a hero.

However, as the book progresses, Macon's personality keeps unfolding. I find myself confused and exasperated with him. For example, when Macon argues with the Black Student Union and slams them for not doing enough, I found myself seriously disliking him. He says he "was on the front lines, way the fuck up in the mix, and they were hibernating in their dorm rooms. Holding meetings. Please." The disdain in his voice for the people who are actually affected every day of their lives by racism and oppression made me think of Macon as an idiot. A pretender who was trying to be real. Perhaps his argument with the African American professor of rap may be more legitimate--I think students should be allowed to raise counterarguments--but here, Macon was belittling everybody else and purporting his own opinions. 

Yet, there is this sense that Macon knows what he's talking about. He says over and over again that he isn't like other white boys who listen to rap--they do it because it's fashionable, he does it because he actually cares about what rap is saying. In the argument with the professor, Macon is depicted as a hero--the first person to question the legitimacy of the professor's statements. The risks that Macon goes to prove himself should also be mentioned: he starts robbing white people, lands in jail for a day, and gets maced. Of course, one could argue that Macon was only in jail for a short period of time and that he might not have robbed whites solely for the sake of the black community...

I was surprised by the skill with which Macon handled many of his interviews--excluding the Rise and Shine New York show. He was always one step ahead of the interviewer and easily countered their statements. Many of the things he mentioned were valid--everyday racism, micro aggression, white privilege--yet it still made me slightly uncomfortable because Macon takes such a radical stance on such a sensitive topic as a white person. 

Angry Black White Boy definitely has me intrigued. I still don't know how to feel about Macon--while he says some things that resonate with me, the way he carries it out is troubling. For example, when Macon starts grilling the host of the Rise and Shine New York show and uses the n-word repeatedly, even Andre felt uncomfortable. I predict that things will get even more uncomfortable  and strange with the creation of Day of Apology. 

10 comments:

  1. It's definitely true that figuring out Macon's character has been a rollercoaster ride from the beginning. For me at least, I decided that I didn't like him early on and continued not liking him for the rest of the book. Most of why I didn't like him was because of his approach to helping the black cause. While using these big publicity stunts does a good job of raising discussion about the issue, Macon's motive behind these stunts seems kind of unclear to me: is it because he actually cares for the cause or because he wants to be "seen" or noticed? This ambiguity is seen in the part that you mentioned about the interview on Rise and Shine New York where Macon keeps using the n-word. If you're white and down for the cause, you should know not to use that word.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Macon has been a weird character. I basically didn't like him, but there were some things that I agreed. It was interesting to see how he reacted the interviews. I think that if we were just people listening to the radio, he'd seem like a reasonable guy, but we know his inner monologue which shows that he is much more problematic than he seems.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It's clear that, for better or worse, Macon isn't working from any "master plan"--he's winging this whole thing, from start to finish, with a little bit of influence from Nique and Andre. There's no *intention* for the robberies to lead to this publicity, but once the microphone is in front of him, Macon (usually) does a pretty good job. He attributes this to his training in hip-hop culture, his ability to think fast and reply with some verbal wit, but also to his tendency to respond aggressively and defensively. His improvisatory verbal skills are a kind of "superpower," as Macon describes it at one point, but this power doesn't always work in his favor.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Macon has a great talent for thinking on the spot, and making up something to get people to move to action. Even though the things he says are often problematic and make people uncomfortable, he address topics that are too often left unaddressed, and likely to cause more problems in the future. Macon puts himself out there and even though his on-the-fly plans don't work out, he is still trying to make a difference.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Finishing the novel adds even more levels of confusion to Macon's character, as now he has technically died for his cause. However, his motivations don't always seem clear, and in general I have found myself disliking Macon the further the novel goes on. Though, as you have said, he is a confusing character to read and think about.

    ReplyDelete
  6. I agree with you in that it is hard to evaluate Macon when he does so many outrageous things that he is convinced are helping him propagate his image. Macon is very knowledgeable in black culture, something that he constantly prides himself in, but the fact that he is willing to go to such great lengths, such as placing himself in extremely awkward scenarios concerning race and randomly robbing people for some sense of justice causes us to be wary of how we look at him throughout the novel.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Figuring out Macon's character has definitely been a large part of this book. Are the good things Macon brings up smeared by his personality and abrasiveness? Would people be willing to listen to someone like Macon?

    ReplyDelete
  8. Macon is definitely written as a purposefully complex character -- with more negatives to him than positives. But I agree with you that it is really hard to figure out how he could have been a "perfect" advocate for good race relations. Of course being a supporter rather than a movement maker as well as being less militant with his actions would be a good start, but could someone like Macon ever become a social justice warrior?

    ReplyDelete
  9. I agree totally with you. Macon is a very hard character to figure out. The way he talks just rubs me the wrong way sometimes. Even at the end of the book, I'm not sure how I feel.

    ReplyDelete
  10. i am very impressed with your lovely post.. i am so glad to left comment on this.. This has been a so interesting read. mcx tips

    ReplyDelete